“…[M]y own view is that she should have given [the ring] back,” Associate Justice James R. Milkey wrote of the former bride-to-be in a dissenting opinion. “But why should my personal view on this issue matter? To me, the ultimate question this case poses is whether such issues should be resolved in courts of law, or instead left to the interplay between private conscience and social norms.”

       

Click Here To Read The Full Article